A Winning Game Plan Takes More Than Great Players
November 19, 2026
By Chris Haacke
Here in Cincinnati, we love our Bengals. Over the years, they have also taught us an important lesson: a roster filled with talented players does not automatically produce a winning team.
The same principle applies to a self-funded health plan. An employer may select an excellent broker, third-party administrator, pharmacy benefit manager, stop-loss carrier, and specialized solution providers. Yet if those partners are not working from the same game plan, the employer can still experience fragmented reporting, implementation problems, employee frustration, and disappointing plan results.
Why Health Plan Partners Need One Game Plan
One advantage of self-funded health plans is the flexibility employers have in building a plan around their specific needs. A broker brings strategic guidance. A third-party administrator, or TPA, manages plan administration. A pharmacy benefit manager, or PBM, oversees pharmacy benefits, while a stop-loss carrier provides financial protection against high-cost claims. Other specialized partners may provide services such as employee assistance programs, specialty pharmacy assistance, and centers of excellence, and that specialization creates meaningful value.
At Custom Design Benefits, we know what we do well as a TPA, and we recognize that other organizations bring expertise and capabilities that can make a real difference for the employers we serve. We are not interested in pretending we have every solution under one roof.
What interests me is how we bring those capabilities together. A self-funded health plan does not operate as a collection of independent services. It is a connected system in which a decision made by one partner can affect the work of several others. Having a shared strategy does not necessarily mean everyone understands their role in carrying it out.
Where Vendor Coordination Affects Plan Administration
Consider an employer that wants to get a better handle on specialty medication spending. The broker identifies rising specialty pharmacy costs as a concern, and CDB brings forward a specialized program through one of our integrated pharmacy partners with promising savings opportunities. The employer decides to move forward. It sounds like a good play, but identifying the solution is only the beginning.
Behind every data exchange and administrative handoff is a real employee or family member trying to access care. If eligibility or authorization information does not reach the right organization at the right time, that member may encounter a delay or denial at the pharmacy counter. If reporting is not aligned, the employer may struggle to tell whether the program is working. And if no one owns an issue, the employer’s HR team may end up coordinating conversations among multiple partners.
We saw this firsthand during the implementation of a specialty medication cost-management program for one of our employer clients. The program itself was sound, but the client wanted to understand its benefits, its reporting capabilities, and, most importantly, the member experience. CDB worked with the vendor to create a customized presentation, then met with the client and their broker partner to walk through the process from start to finish and plan how to educate members. That collaboration resolved questions before they became member-service problems and gave the employer a clearer way to evaluate results. The lesson was straightforward: selecting the right solution matters, but the quality of the implementation often determines whether employees actually experience the value that solution was intended to provide.
Are Your Partners Measuring Success the Same Way?
Now consider an employer that sits down for a plan review and hears encouraging news from its PBM: a specialty medication program has produced substantial savings. That is the kind of report everyone likes to hear. But then the TPA presents its data, and overall claims spending has increased. How can both things be true?
The reports may be measuring different outcomes. The PBM could be reporting savings within a particular program against an established benchmark, while the TPA could be measuring spending across the entire health plan. Higher costs elsewhere may have offset some or all of those program-level savings. Neither report is necessarily wrong, but each is telling only part of the story.
Employers need more than individual reports to understand how their health plans are performing. A meaningful review should reconcile the methodology, benchmark, measurement period, implementation costs, rebates or credits, and the effect on actual paid claims.
That requires partners to look beyond their own results. When the TPA, broker, PBM, and specialized partners are willing to share information and examine what is happening across the plan, they can give the employer a much more complete understanding of performance. After all, a team can make impressive plays throughout a game and still come up short on the scoreboard.
When Does Another Health Plan Partner Make Sense?
One thing I have learned over the years is that employers do not create a better health plan simply by adding more partners. They do not necessarily create one by limiting the number of partners, either.
Sometimes an employer needs a specialized solution that its existing partners are not equipped to provide. Other times, the better opportunity is to improve how the current partners are working together. Knowing the difference is important.
At CDB, we value relationships with organizations that bring different perspectives and specialized expertise to the table. The value goes beyond knowing whom to call. It comes from understanding how to work together, recognizing when something is not going as planned, and addressing problems rather than passing them along to someone else.
Three Questions Employers Should Ask Their Partners
Employers have more opportunities to influence how their health plan partners work together than football fans have over what happens on Sunday. When evaluating current or prospective partnerships, I encourage employers to ask three questions:
1. Do our partners understand where their responsibilities overlap?
Clarify what information must be shared, who owns each implementation step, and how issues involving more than one organization will be resolved.
2. Are we looking at the full picture of plan performance?
Vendor reports should contribute to a unified view of spending, savings, utilization, member experience, and operational performance rather than leaving the employer to reconcile the information alone.
3. Who keeps the work moving when something does not go as planned?
Employers should understand how their partners escalate questions, coordinate solutions, and accept ownership for shared responsibilities.
Because the TPA sits at the intersection of eligibility, claims administration, plan documents, member service, reporting, and vendor data, CDB often has visibility into how a change in one area affects the rest of the plan. That does not mean taking over another partner’s responsibilities. It means helping identify dependencies, clarify handoffs, and keep the employer’s overall objectives in view.
CDB is here for you. Ultimately, employers are not paying for a talented roster of vendor partners. They are investing in a health plan that needs a winning strategy, and we will help clarify responsibilities and build a more complete understanding of plan performance to get there.
Let’s go, Bengals!